When Is It Time to Leave?

We’ve been welcomed, and we’ve been shunned. The wandering people have come and gone from many countries. Our story of coming to a new land begins in Genesis with Abraham. Our story of leaving a place where we had been welcomed begins with Jacob. And once again, we ask: when is it time to leave?

Jacob fled the wrath of his brother Esau and found shelter in his uncle Laban’s home in Haran. There he fell in love with Rachel, only to be tricked by Laban into marrying her older sister, Leah, first. After twenty years, Jacob had built flocks that rivaled his uncle’s wealth. When he noticed that Laban’s demeanor toward him had changed (Genesis 31:2), Jacob planned his escape.

Jewish history is replete with similar stories. Polish rulers welcomed Jews into their territories, only for later generations to turn on them. At the start of the 20th century, Jews made up a quarter to a third of Baghdad’s population and were pillars of its commerce. By 1951, nearly all of them were gone.

Some American Jews are bewildered by the surge in antisemitism after what Franklin Foer called the Golden Age of American Jews. Historian Pamela Nadell is less surprised. She titled her book Antisemitism, an American Tradition.

Is Jacob’s story on repeat? Jews in America have settled here and prospered. We’ve married American daughters and raised our families here. But Laban’s demeanor toward us has changed. Is it time to leave?

I believe the answer is “not yet.” When the new Congress convenes in January, it will include ten Jewish senators and 28 Jewish members of the House. Seven Jewish governors will be in office. At least five of the leading contenders for the 2028 presidency are Jewish. Four of the ten wealthiest Americans are Jewish. Jews in Weimar Germany also reached high office and great wealth, so success alone guarantees nothing. But one major factor is different: we have learned how to organize and make our voices heard.

We understand that we must be proactive, meeting our neighbors and forming alliances. That is the work of the American Jewish Committee and local interfaith councils. We must not cower; we must walk proudly as Jews. That was the story in Philadelphia on November 8, the eve of the Kristallnacht anniversary. A “boycott ride” targeting six Jewish-owned restaurants was met by hundreds of counterprotesters and hundreds more Philadelphians, Jews and non-Jews alike, who waited in long lines to buy lunch from the targeted businesses.

So stop browsing real estate listings in Costa Rica. Start calling your representatives to express your concerns about the future of America as a safe home for Jews and all other minority groups. Stop obsessing over Hasan Piker and Tucker Carlson, and support the pundits and politicians who have our back.

Let’s change the question from “Is it time to leave?” to “How do we make it safe to stay?”

Rabbi Evan J. Krame

If this reflection resonates with you, consider sharing it on social media—or simply take a moment to reflect on how you can create a better community.

Evan Krame

Blogs & Writings

Insights, stories, and reflections on Jewish life, tradition, and community. Explore our latest articles to deepen your connection and understanding.